OEA Retirement Systems Update – October 2012

Distribution: Board of Directors, Local Presidents, District Leaders, Legislative
Committee, OEA-R, OEA Staff

OEA Retirement Systems Update
Report to the OEA Board of Directors: October 2012

Please distribute to other OEA members

Passage of Pension Legislation Brings New Retirement Considerations

Recent passage of pension reform legislation (SB 341, 342 and 343) was needed in
order to help secure the long-term solvency of the retirement benefits that our
members rely upon. However, these were difficult changes. This represents the
first time in Ohio history that pension benefits were decreased. The changes affect
individuals differently depending on which system they belong to, their age, years
of service and other factors. For many, this means working longer. For those who
are currently eligible to retire or in the latter stages of their careers, the
changes may raise questions about when to retire.

There are many factors that go into retirement planning. Not the least among these
factors are job satisfaction and whether an individual can afford to retire.
Retirement likely means a significant reduction in income and increased health care
costs. However, we want members to have timely and accurate information in order to
make these decisions. Below are some considerations raised by the new rules coming
into effect. This is not intended as retirement advice. Members are encouraged to
contact their retirement system for additional information and retirement scenarios
based on their individual circumstance.

STRS (Senate Bill 342):

STRS Members Currently Eligible to Retire: Changes in the cost-of-living adjustment
(COLA) go into effect in July 2013. Members who retire any time before July 1, 2013
will not receive a COLA during the 2014 fiscal year (July 1, 2013-June 30, 2014).
Members who retire effective July 1, 2013 will not receive a COLA on July 1, 2014.
After missing one COLA, retirees will resume COLAs at 2% per year. Those who retire
AFTER July 1, 2013 will not receive a cost-of-living adjustment (COLA) for 60
months. This delay results in a significant loss of lifetime retirement earnings.

Changes in the benefit formula go into effect in 2015. The current 35-year enhanced
benefit formula will be eliminated after July 1, 2015 and those who have not reached
35 years of service at that point will not be eligible. Teachers reaching 35 years
of service as of August 1, 2015 or later will receive 77% (35 x 2.2%) of their final
average salary as a pension. Members who are eligible to retire on July 1, 2015 will
maintain retirement eligibility if they continue working and the benefit will be the
greater of:

* (a) The benefit calculated upon retirement under the new benefit formula, or

* (b) The benefit as of July 1, 2015 under the current formula.
STRS Members Nearing Retirement Eligibility: Changes in retirement eligibility
begin in 2015 and are phased-in over time. Those who fall short of being eligible
to retire as of July 1, 2015 will become eligible according to the following charts:

Unreduced Benefit
for Retirement Between:

Minimum Age and
Years of Service


Any age and 30 years of service


Any age and 31 years of service


Any age and 32 years of service


Any age and 33 years of service


Any age and 34 years of service


Any age and 35 years of service


Age 60 and 35 years of service

Members may also retire with full benefits at age 65 with at least five years of
service credit. The chart below shows eligibility for early retirement. Early
retirements will be subject to an actuarial reduction in benefits.
Actuarially Reduced Benefit*
for Retirement Between:

Minimum Age and
Years of Service


Age 55 and 25 years of service


30 years of service or age 55 and 26 years of service


30 years of service or age 55 and 27 years of service


30 years of service or age 55 and 28 years of service


30 years of service or age 55 and 29 years of service


30 years of service


Age 60 and 5 years of service

STRS Members with Purchasable Service Credit: Effective January 1, 2014 members
will pay the full projected liability created by the purchase of service. This could
result in costs two-to-four times higher than under the current rates. For service
credit certified with STRS by December 31, 2013, members will have until June 30,
2014 to purchase the credit at current cost. Members currently purchasing under a
payroll deduction plan can continue to complete their payoff at their current rate.

For review, below is a summary of the major changes made by SB 342.

Retirement Eligibility: Retirement with full benefits at age 65 with at least 5
years of service is maintained. Otherwise, beginning in 2015, the years of service
needed to retire with full benefits gradually increases from 30 years to 35 years.
After 2026, a member would need to have 35 years of service and be at least 60 years
old for full benefits.

For early retirements, members could retire at age 60 with 5 years of service or
with 30 years of service at any age. However, members who choose to retire early
would have their benefits actuarially reduced.

Contributions: Increase in member contributions by 4% of pay phased in 1% a year
beginning July 1, 2013 through July 1, 2016.

Cost-of-Living Allowance (COLA): The bill would lower the COLA rate for current
retirees from 3% to 2% and have a freeze on increases for FY 2014. For future
retirees (beginning August 2013), the COLA rate would also be 2%, but the first
increase would come after 60 months of retirement.

Benefit Formula and Final Average Salary (FAS): Beginning in 2015, the formula
would be 2.2% for each year of service and final average salary would be calculated
on five years of salary rather than three. Those who are eligible to retire by July
1, 2015, but elect to continue working, could receive no less of a base benefit than
current law allows.

SERS (Senate Bill 341)

The SERS plan does not call for changes in contribution rates, COLA, formula or
final average salary. The current fiscal condition of SERS does not warrant such
changes. This is important due to the low wages of many educational support
personnel and the low monthly pensions of the average SERS retiree.

Retirement Eligibility: Beginning August 1 2017, retirement eligibility with full
benefits would be 10 years of service at age 67 or 30 years of service at age 57. A
member could retire early with 10 years of service at age 62 or 25 years of service
at age 60. Early retirements would be subject to an actuarial reduction of
benefits. Members who would have at least 25 years of service by 2017 are
grandfathered from these changes.

OPERS (Senate Bill 343)

OPERS Members Currently Eligible to Retire: Those OPERS who are eligible to retire
in the next five years are in “Group A” and grandfathered from the majority of
changes made in SB 343. One exception is the change in cost-of-living allowance
(COLA). Those who retire prior to the bill’s effective date (January 7, 2013) will
receive an annual COLA of 3%. Everyone who retires after that point will have their
COLA based on the Consumer Price Index (CPI) not to exceed 3%. In addition to the
pension changes contained in SB 343, OPERS is making changes to its health care
program that affects those who retire prior to January 1, 2014 differently than
those who retire after that point. More information on the OPERS health care
changes is provided later in this update.

Those who are contemplating retiring prior to the January 7, 2013 effective date of
new legislation must be off their employer’s payroll by the end of the year. OPERS
needs a valid, completed retirement application by the close of business Jan. 4,
2013 if applying using paper forms, or by midnight Jan. 6, 2013 if applying online.

Below is a summary of the major changes in SB 343.

Retirement Eligibility: For Group B, eligibility for full benefits increases to 31
years of service and age 52, 32 years of service at any age, or five years of
service at age 66. For Group C, eligibility for full benefits increases to 32 years
of service at age 55 or five years of service at age 67. For both groups, early
retirements result in actuarially reduced benefits. Group A is grandfathered into
current eligibility requirements.

Formula and FAS: For Group C only, the formula would be 2.2% for the first 35 years
and 2.5% for each year thereafter with FAS calculated on the five highest years of
salary (up from 3).

Cost-of-Living Allowance (COLA): The COLA would remain 3% for current retirees.
For those retiring after the bill’s effective date (Groups A, B and C), the COLA
would be the increase in the Consumer Price Index (CPI) capped at 3%. The effective
date of the bill is January 7, 2013.

OPERS Adopts Changes for Health Care Program

At its September Board meeting, the OPERS Board voted to make substantial changes to
the OPERS health care program. The changes were necessary because the current
level of OPERS health care benefits is estimated to require 7.6% of payroll in order
to be sustained. The recently passed pension legislation for OPERS (SB 343) is
estimated to allow for 4% of payroll, from the employer contribution, to be
dedicated to health care going forward. The Board voted to make a number of changes
beginning in January 2014. Some of these changes are phased-in over time. Below is
a listing of some of the major changes:

* Access to health care coverage limited to those with 30 years of service
or those 60 years or older with at least 20 years of service. This applies to those
who retire after January 1, 2014. Those who retire prior to that date are
grandfathered and retain eligibility with at least 10 years of service credit.

* The premium subsidy will be based on a chart that factors in years of
service and age at retirement. Subsidy percentages range from 51% to 90%. Current
retirees will transition to new rates over a three year phase-in period. Current
retirees will have a minimum subsidy rate of 75% if they are receiving a 75% or
greater subsidy now.

* No subsidy for spouses. Beginning in 2019, spouses under 65 will not have
access to OPERS health care coverage.

* Phase-out of Medicare Part B premium reimbursement.
Changes in OPERS pension and health care benefits may cause members who are eligible
to retire or will soon be eligible to retire to question the timing of their
retirement or re-evaluate their plans. There can be significant differences in
health care eligibility and subsidy levels for those who retire before January 1,
2014 and those who retire afterwards. These changes are complex; and there are many
factors to consider in making retirement decisions. OPERS has detailed information
about the health care changes on its website www.opers.org.
Members are encouraged to review this information and contact OPERS at
1-800-222-PERS (7377) with individual questions.

Watch the new Yes on Issue 2 television ad

Watch the new Yes on Issue 2 television ad

Dear OEA Members:
We wanted you to see the new Yes on Issue 2 television ad.

With less than two weeks to go and early voting underway, please urge your friends,
family members, co-workers and neighbors to Vote Yes on Issue 2.

We need to put citizens in charge of fair districts and competitive elections.

Go to
to learn more about a Yes Vote for Issue 2.


You are allowed to have union representation during your evaluation, Maybe!

Amendment to email sent on Wednesday, October 24, 2012 11:57 AM

Previously you received the following:

Greetings OEA member leaders:

The following question was raised at one of the AR trainings. Thanks for the
question Georgia!
Can you have an Association Representative with you during job evaluations?

At the time, I believe I said that not unless there was reason to believe the
meeting could lead to discipline. Then, of course, your members should invoke their
Weingarten rights as we discussed.

I amend my advice given the following.
The State Employment Relations Board has determined that job evaluations may be
disciplinary in nature, so you are entitled to have a representative at any of those
Per consult with OEA’s law firm, Cloppert, Latanick, Sauter and Washburn,
The statement in bold above is not correct.
“This use to be the law under the Trotwood Madison case, SERB 90-012 (5-19-89).
This case was reversed by SERB in the In re Davenport case, SERB 95-023 (12-29-95).
The language presented in the handout that I previously sent to you outlines SERB’s
opinion in Davenport. I think that you could argue that a representative could be
in an evaluation conference if the teacher thought that it would lead to discipline;
however, this is not true in your average run of the mill evaluation conference.”

NOTICE: This message may be confidential and legally protected from disclosure by
the attorney/client privilege. If you are not the -named recipient, or an employee
or agent responsible for delivering this message to the named recipient, take notice
that any distribution or copying of this message is prohibited. If you received
this message in error, please immediately reply to the sender via return email, and
delete it from your computer. Thank you. CLS&W, Attorneys-at-Law.
Sorry to all for the confusion.
Given the political climate, its best to include language in newly negotiated
evaluation provisions that allows all our members representation and due process
during any evaluation meeting.

Best Regards,

Dolores Tufaro

OEA Campaign Email

OEA Campaign Email

*** Stand Up in 2012
*** OEA’s Campaign 2012 Electyronic Newsletter

** U.S. Supreme Court rebuffs Secretary of State Husted,
** Ohioans to vote early in-person November 3-5

The United States Supreme Court has decided not to hear any appeal
over early in-person voting in Ohio for the last three days before the
November 6 election. Ohio Secretary of State Jon Husted, who sought to
eliminate the last three days of voting, immediately set a schedule
for in-person voting through a statewide directive:

* Saturday, November 3, 8 a.m.-2 p.m.
* Sunday, November 4, 1-5 p.m.
* Monday, November 5, 8 a.m.-2 p.m.

** Message on Issue 2 is getting past the malarkey:
** Vote Yes on 2 – When elections are fair, the people win

Politifact Ohio helped sort out fact from fiction recently,
(http://aces.ohea.org/site/R?i=4cHbUT6Unk2Au1GixVH7pA , explaining that Ohio
Secretary of State Jon Husted was nowhere close to the truth when he said members of
the Independent Citizens Redistricting Commission could not be removed for bribery.
To learn more and help set the record straight by writing a letter to the
editor, please go to http://aces.ohea.org/site/R?i=0z0ByR_UOvlP0PHF5YfO2Q .


Meaningful reform and competitive elections are possible with a YES
vote on Issue 2. But letting politicians draw their own district lines
is like letting the fox guard the henhouse. Public Policy Polling now
shows Issue 2 Yes voters at 37%, no voters at 44%, with a great
opportunity to persuade the undecided voters. This is major progress
for Voters First redistricting reform advocates and increases the
likelihood of passage for Issue 2.

** Presidential debates in Town Hall format
** reveal who will protect public education

President Barack Obama proved his expertise on foreign policy and the
economy in the second of three presidential debates Tuesday evening,
challenging former Massachusetts Governor Mitt Romney to explain how
his across-the-board tax cuts and higher levels of military spending
could ever balance the budget. The President proved to be a strong
advocate for federal education funding and expanding student loans for
college as strategies to provide more high-paying and rewarding jobs
and careers. One thing both campaigns agree on: Ohio voters will have
a decisive role in determining the winner of this year’s
presidential election.

** Don’t forget next week’s watch parties for the final
** debate between Obama and Romney on Monday, October 22:

* 8-11 p.m., Gresso’s, 961 South High Street, Columbus, OH 43206.
RSVP to mckayb@ohea.org or 614-227-3056.
* 9- 10:30 p.m., NEOEA Office, 5422 East 96th Street, Garfield
Heights, OH 44125, RSVP to 216-518-0200.
* 8- 10:30 p.m., Phil Long’s residence, 617 Devonshire Drive,
Celina, OH 45822. RSVP to jacksons@ohea.org or 937-335-4544.
* 8:15 p.m. Sons of Italy, 3348 Belmont Street, Bellaire, OH
43906. RSVP to hudsonb@ohea.org, 1-800-255-5748.
* 9- 11:00 p.m Geneva State Park Lodge, Geneva-on-the-Lake,
Ohio. RSVP to wolfm@ohea.org, 419-865-1837 or
* 8:00 p.m. Holland Office, 7359 International Dr., Unit D,
Holland, Ohio. RSVP to jonesest@ohea.org, 419-865-1837 or
* 8:30 p.m. Lexington Office, 50 Industrial Dr., Lexington,
Ohio. RSVP to davise@ohea.org, or barnettl@ohea.org,
419-884-3980 or 800-325-6244.
* 8:30 p.m. Tiffin Office, 674 Miami St., Ste. A, Tiffin,
Ohio. RSVP to assenheimer@ohea.org, 419-448-1498 or

** See replay of Sherrod Brown and Josh Mandel
** Squaring off in televised Cleveland debate

You can see a full replay of the debate Monday between U.S. Senator
Sherrod Brown and his rival, State Treasurer Josh Mandel, thanks to
YouTube at

Moderator Karen Kasler is a statehouse reporter with Ohio Public
Radio. The two candidates debated tax policy and the deficit,
assistance for the auto industry, healthcare, foreign trade and the
effect of federal policies on these issues on the middle class.
Watch your local listings for a second debate Thursday night in

** OEA members rally to phone banks
** for Obama, Issue 2 and endorsed candidates

In the final 20 days of OEA Campaign 2012, members have poured on the
energy, working at phone banks at dozens of Ohio locations and making
major contributions to the NEA Education Votes Action Center (NEA

* See the complete list of OEA phone bank opportunities here:
* Learn more about how to phone friends and colleagues via NEA
EVAC here: http://aces.ohea.org/site/R?i=-s2SbzDTBoirzDsFGGdkCA
* Join Educators for Obama and make a true difference in the
Presidential election at http://aces.ohea.org/site/R?i=7-t8JsrLNXfSbCf_uHpdLw .

Remember, both phone bank programs offer incentives and rewards for
activism, and OEA offers weekly drawings for great prizes. For the
week of October 8-14, the winners of $25 Barnes & Noble gift cards

* Barbara Niederkorn – Willoughby Eastlake Classified
* Rebecca Sovchik – Cloverleaf Education Association

For a run-down of prizes and drawings please go to
http://aces.ohea.org/site/R?i=fBdioHeksz_UcDcVeVmu6Q .

** Spotlight on Ohio’s Congressional Candidates
** And the OEA Recommendations

Ohio loses two seats in the U.S. House of Representatives next year,
but the Congressional elections are crucial for public education. Here
are OEA’s recommendations:

CD 1 Jeff Sinnard (D)
CD 2 No Position
CD 3 Joyce Beatty (D)
CD 4 Jim Slone (D)
CD 5 Angela Zimmann (D)
CD 6 Charlie Wilson (D)
CD 7 Joyce Healy Abrams (D)
CD 8 No Position
CD 9 Marcy Kaptur (D)
CD 10 Sharen Swartz Neuhardt (D)
CD 11 Marcia Fudge (D)
CD 12 No Position
CD 13 Tim Ryan (D)
CD 14 No Position
CD 15 Pat Lang (D)
CD 16 Betty Sutton (D)

For more information, please visit
the OEA Campaign 2012 website at
http://aces.ohea.org/site/R?i=FbynyW1AestNAJ3QgBsaFA .

For a complete list of OEA-recommended candidates, please log into
the OEA website as a member and then go to

** Stand Up in 2012

Stand Up in 2012 is an electronic newsletter dedicated to members of
the Ohio Education Association, 225 E. Broad St., Columbus, Ohio 43215
www.ohea.org See the OEA Campaign 2012 Website at